
How do you speak to yourself when things go wrong? Perhaps you make a mistake at work and immediately think, that was stupid. You miss a few workouts and tell yourself you’re lazy. You look in the mirror and focus on everything you’d like to change. Or you’re struggling with something difficult and, rather than acknowledging how hard it is, find yourself thinking, I should be coping better than this.
Most of us have an inner voice that evaluates how we’re doing. At times, it can be useful, helping us recognise mistakes, maintain standards and make changes. But when that voice becomes relentlessly critical, it may stop helping us grow and simply leave us feeling that we’re never quite good enough.
In this article, we explore where the inner critic comes from, why being hard on ourselves doesn’t always motivate us in the way we imagine, and how self-compassion can offer a healthier foundation for growth and change.
Where Does the Inner Critic Come From?
Our inner critic doesn’t usually develop because there is something wrong with us. Often, it has learned that criticism is a way of keeping us safe, accepted or successful.
If you tell yourself not to make mistakes, perhaps you hope to avoid embarrassment. If you’re constantly monitoring how you look, you may be trying to protect yourself from judgement. If you push yourself harder when you’re struggling, perhaps you’ve learned that achievement brings approval or security.
In this sense, the inner critic may actually be trying to help. The problem is that its methods can be harsh and often misguided. And, over time, the voice that once encouraged us to work harder or avoid mistakes can become an almost constant commentator on our performance, appearance and worth.
Understanding the inner critic doesn’t mean agreeing with it; it means becoming curious about what it is trying to achieve and whether there might be a kinder way to get there. But for many of us, the idea that there might be a kinder way raises an uncomfortable question: if we stop criticising ourselves, what will motivate us to change?
When Self-Criticism Masquerades as Motivation
Many of us worry that if we stop being hard on ourselves, we’ll become complacent.
We tell ourselves that criticism keeps us disciplined, and this can turn into beliefs that sound like:
- If you don’t push yourself, you’ll never exercise.
- If you accept yourself as you are, you’ll stop trying.
- If you don’t feel bad about this mistake, you’ll make it again.
But motivation driven primarily by criticism comes at a cost. If every setback becomes evidence of personal failure, trying something difficult can begin to feel threatening. You may procrastinate because you’re afraid of getting it wrong, give up because your efforts never feel good enough or achieve your goals while remaining dissatisfied with yourself.
There is an important difference between saying, “This didn’t go the way I wanted; what can I learn?” and “I failed; what’s wrong with me?” Both recognise that something needs to change, but only one requires us to attack ourselves in the process. And learning to respond to ourselves in this way can be particularly challenging in a culture that continually reminds us of all the ways we could be doing, and becoming, better.
The Pressure to Keep Improving
Modern wellness culture can make this particularly complicated. There is always something we could improve: our fitness, diet, sleep, productivity, appearance, stress levels or morning routine. Many of these goals can genuinely support health and wellbeing.
The difficulty arises when caring for ourselves quietly becomes another way of finding ourselves inadequate. For example:
- Exercise shifts from I want to feel stronger to I have to fix my body.
- Eating well becomes a test of discipline.
- Rest has to be earned.
- Ageing becomes something to fight rather than a natural process to navigate.
Wanting to change something about ourselves isn’t inherently unhealthy, and neither is caring about how we look or perform. What matters is the relationship from which that change begins. Looking after yourself and constantly trying to fix yourself are not the same thing.
What If Compassion Is the Stronger Response?
Self-compassion is sometimes misunderstood as being soft on ourselves, lowering our standards or making excuses, but it is none of these things. Compassion means recognising difficulty and responding to it with an intention to help rather than harm. We do this instinctively with people we care about. If a friend is struggling, we can acknowledge what went wrong while still treating them with warmth and perspective.
We can learn to offer ourselves the same response. For example:
- Instead of: “Why can’t I get anything right?”, we might ask, “What happened here, and what do I need to do differently?”
- Instead of “I should be coping better”, perhaps we might think, “This is difficult. What would support me right now?”
Contrary to popular belief, self-compassion doesn’t remove responsibility. It allows us to take responsibility without turning every difficulty into a judgement about who we are. Why does this matter?
Our Brains Need More Than Drive
One useful way of understanding this comes from compassion-focused psychology, which describes different systems involved in regulating our emotions.
- Our threat system helps us detect danger and respond quickly.
- Our drive system motivates us to pursue goals, achieve and acquire things we value. Both are essential.
But we also have capacities associated with soothing, safety and connection, the experiences that allow us to settle, recover and feel supported. Problems can arise when our lives become dominated by threat and drive: What’s wrong? What needs doing? What haven’t I achieved? What’s next?
If you’re someone accustomed to functioning this way, slowing down or responding compassionately to yourself can initially feel uncomfortable, and even undeserved.
Yet sustainable wellbeing isn’t created by continually pushing harder. Sometimes what helps you move forward is not more pressure, but enough internal safety to stop fighting yourself. One place to begin creating that sense of internal safety is surprisingly close to home: by paying attention to the way you speak to yourself.
Changing the Way You Speak to Yourself
Most of us wouldn’t speak to someone we care about in the way we sometimes speak to ourselves. That doesn’t mean replacing every difficult thought with a positive affirmation. If something has gone badly, telling yourself everything is wonderful isn’t particularly helpful either. What is needed is a more balance and compassionate inner voice, which can be both kind and honest.
Let’s reflect on what that might look like…Try noticing what you say to yourself when something goes wrong. Then ask: Would I say this to someone I cared about in the same situation?
If not, how could you say it differently without avoiding the truth? Here are some ideas:
- I made a mistake, but mistakes happen. What can I learn from it?
- I’ve had a difficult week. Missing a workout doesn’t undo everything I’ve done.
- My body is changing. I can decide what I want to do about that without attacking myself for it.
The aim isn’t positive thinking. It’s fairer thinking. For some of us, though, speaking to ourselves this way can feel almost too gentle, raising the question we encountered earlier: if we accept ourselves as we are, does that mean giving up on change?
Compassion Doesn’t Mean Standing Still
Perhaps one of the most important things to understand about self-compassion is that acceptance and change are not opposites. You can accept yourself and still want to become stronger. You can treat your body with respect and still have goals for your fitness or appearance. You can acknowledge that you’re doing your best and still recognise that something needs to change.
In fact, compassion can sometimes make change easier because failure becomes less threatening. If getting something wrong doesn’t automatically lead to self-attack, there is more room to experiment, learn and begin again.
This creates a very different foundation for wellbeing. Rather than asking, “What’s wrong with me and how do I fix it?”, we can begin asking, “What matters to me, and how can I support myself in moving towards it?”
Take-Home Message: Become Someone Who Is on Your Side
I’d like to leave you with a simple question: When life becomes difficult, what kind of coach do you become for yourself?
A good coach doesn’t pretend mistakes haven’t happened or tell us that effort doesn’t matter. They challenge us when necessary, recognise when we need support and help us keep perspective when things don’t go according to plan. We can learn to offer ourselves the same balance.
Self-compassion isn’t about giving up on growth. It is about recognising that you don’t have to dislike yourself into becoming healthier, stronger or happier version of yourself. And perhaps genuine wellbeing begins when your desire to change comes not from the belief that you are inadequate, but from the understanding that you are worth caring for.
You can want more for yourself while still being on your own side. If you’d like support with your mental or emotional wellbeing, contact the Neuromed team to explore the services and support available to you.
Contact us at our Galway office (091) 379 215, Dublin office (01) 965 3294 or email info@neuromedclinic.com.
Dr. Susan McGarvie
Mindfulness-Based Therapeutic Coach
Dr. Susan McGarvie works with adults to support personal change and growth using mindfulness, positive psychology, and coaching. With over 20 years of experience across healthcare, nonprofits, and academia, her work combines evidence-based practice with compassionate, practical support.

